| Date & Time | Game | Venue |
|---|---|---|
| December 16, 2023 | (3) Hingham Harbormen at (2) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| December 20, 2023 | (1) La Salle Academy at (3) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| December 23, 2023 | (3) St. John's Prep Eagles at (2) Bishop Feehan Shamrocks | New England Sports Village |
| December 27, 2023 | (0) BC High Eagles at (3) St. John's Prep Eagles
Pete Frates Classic |
Essex Sports Center |
| December 28, 2023 | (0) Pope Francis Cardinals at (1) St. John's Prep Eagles
Peter Frates Classic Championship Game |
Essex Sports Center |
| January 01, 2024 | (3) St. John's Prep Eagles at (0) Reading Rockets | Burbank Ice Arena |
| January 06, 2024 | (5) St. John's Prep Eagles at (1) Malden Catholic Lancers | Valley Forum II |
| January 10, 2024 | (5) St. John's Prep Eagles at (2) Xaverian Hawks | Canton Ice House |
| January 14, 2024 | (4) St. John's Prep Eagles at (1) Catholic Memorial Knights
Catholic Conference Showcase |
Canton Ice House |
| January 17, 2024 | (6) St. John's Prep Eagles at (1) Saint John's Shrewsbury Pioneers | New England Sports Center |
| January 21, 2024 | (5) St. John's Prep Eagles at (2) BC High Eagles | Clark Athletic Center |
| January 24, 2024 | (1) Malden Catholic Lancers at (5) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| January 27, 2024 | (1) Xaverian Hawks at (6) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| January 31, 2024 | (2) Catholic Memorial Knights at (1) St. John's Prep Eagles
CM wins in OT |
Essex Sports Center |
| February 03, 2024 | (1) St. John's Prep Eagles at (3) Arlington Catholic Cougars | Ed Burns Arena |
| February 07, 2024 | (0) St. Mary's Lynn Spartans at (6) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| February 10, 2024 | (2) Newburyport Clippers at (6) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| February 14, 2024 | (0) Andover Golden Warriors at (4) St. John's Prep Eagles | Essex Sports Center |
| February 17, 2024 | (3) Saint John's Shrewsbury Pioneers at (4) St. John's Prep Eagles
SJP wins in OT |
Essex Sports Center |
| February 21, 2024 | (3) St. John's Prep Eagles at (1) Franklin Panthers | Pirelli Veterans Arena |
| February 28, 2024 | (2) Lincoln-Sudbury Warriors at (6) St. John's Prep Eagles
MIAA D1 BOYS STATE TOURNAMENT - Round 32 |
Essex Sports Center |
| March 02, 2024 | (1) Wellesley Raiders at (7) St. John's Prep Eagles
MIAA D1 BOYS STATE TOURNAMENT - SWEET 16 |
Essex Sports Center |
| March 07, 2024 | (0) Hingham Harbormen at (3) St. John's Prep Eagles
MIAA D1 Boys State Tournament - Elite 8 |
Stoneham Arena |
| March 10, 2024 | (0) Xaverian Hawks at (4) St. John's Prep Eagles
MIAA D1 BOYS STATE TOURNAMENT - Final 4 |
Loring Arena |
| March 17, 2024 | (2) Winchester Red & Black at (3) St. John's Prep Eagles
MIAA D1 BOYS STATE TOURNAMENT - State Championship |
TD Garden |
